BROGUES: Yay or Nay?(aka Oxford shoes)

The first time i saw this shoe, i fell in love. A silver one, nd i couldn't resist. I know most of you are reading this with a smirk on your faces, i know, i know.....looks boyish! All the better, easy to pair pair up, with skinny jeans, skirts, dressses,even shorts. Crop up your jeans at the bottom to show them off. Like this:With skirts:With Dresses:With shorts or tights: